Run a free check →
Sample report. A real, unedited free check of a well-known business, run on 2026-10-06. WhatsMyRep has no relationship with this business. Run your own check.

Reputation report · Joe's Pizza · United States

2
Risk 2 / 3 · Could hurt the business
Negative content a buyer is likely to see. Take a look soon.
Country
United States
Checked
2026-10-06
16:42 UTC
Signals checked
111

What to do next

  1. 2
    My daughter ordered (1) large pizza from Joe's Pizza & ...
    Google "Joe's Pizza scam", #6 · Facebook group with multiple overcharge complaints at Joe's Pizza & Pasta.
    Open the page and decide: reply, correct the facts, or ask the site to update it.
  2. 1
    r/Pizza - Joe's Pizza in NYC is worth the hype
    Google "Joe's Pizza reviews", #1 · Reddit thread with mixed-to-negative comments about quality decline, crunch loss.
  3. 1
    Beware of scammers on Joe's Pizza page with fake links
    Google "Joe's Pizza scam", #1 · Facebook warning about scammers using fake Joe's Pizza page with fraudulent posts.
  4. 1
    Inside Job Scam : r/UberEATS
    Google "Joe's Pizza scam", #2 · Reddit report of payment scam during UberEats order from Joe's Pizza NYC.
  5. 1
    Joe's Pizza - Restaurant Reviews
    Google "Joe's Pizza complaints", #2 · Review site with mixed rating 3.4/5, positive snippets but below threshold
  6. 1
    I GOT SCAMMED BY A PIZZA. Three years of living in NYC ...
    Google "Joe's Pizza scam", #3 · Instagram post about fake Joe's Pizza on UberEats; real Joe's clarified counterfeit.

Google results United States, top 10

Search suggestions 40 with your name

Google

  • joe's pizza nyc0
  • joe's pizza reviews0
  • joe's pizza0
  • joe's pizza spiderman 20
  • joe's pizza restaurant0
  • joe's pizza new york0
  • joe's pizza spiderman location0
  • joe's pizza roodhouse illinois0

Bing

  • joe's pizza0
  • joe's pizza spiderman0
  • joe's pizza ri0
  • joe's pizza nyc0
  • joe's pizza streator0
  • joe's pizza robinson il0
  • joe's pizza menu0
  • joe's pizza santa monica0

Ratings Google Maps and review sites

Yelp4.2★★★★☆ 2,864 reviews · JOE'S PIZZA - Updated October 2026 - 2864 Reviews0
Tripadvisor4.3★★★★☆ 912 reviews · JOE'S PIZZA, New York City - 1435 Bdwy, Midtown0

Daily monitoring stores the review counts of your Google Maps places and of review sites every day. A sudden wave, far more new reviews than usual for the business together with a lower rating, sends an alert the same day.

Reddit, YouTube and news what Google shows for the exact name

Found through Google search in the United States: Reddit threads and YouTube videos that Google ranks for the name in quotes, news from the Google News tab for the last 30 days. News links open through Google.

AI answers

Google AI Overview Tone: positiveMentions you0

Yes, Joe's Pizza is a completely legitimate , historic New York City institution that has been serving classic slices since 1975. Joe's Pizza Overview and Reputation - Established: Founded in 1975 by Joe Pozzuoli , an immigrant from Naples, Italy. Wikipedia +1 - Style: The quintessential, no-frills New York thin-crust, foldable slice with a crispy undercarriage and balanced sauce-to-cheese ratio. Reddit +1 - Pricing: Very affordable, running $5.00 for a plain cheese slice, $6.00 for one-topping or specialty slices, and $7.00 for supreme slices. Yelp +1 The Verdict: Is It Worth It? - The Pros: Locals and food critics widely consider it the benchmark for a fast, reliable, classic NYC street slice. The lines move extremely fast, and the quality remains dependable for a quick bite or late-night stop (many locations are open until 3:00 AM). Yelp +4 - The Cons: Because of its immense fame and ...

For “is Joe's Pizza legit” · sources: reddit.com, reddit.com, reddit.com, joespizzanyc.com, tripadvisor.com

ChatGPT Tone: positiveKnows you in 3 of 3 runs0

“Joe’s Pizza” can refer to several unrelated pizzerias, so reputation depends on the location. If you mean the well-known New York City Joe’s Pizza (founded in 1975), it is generally considered reputable and popular, especially for classic New York–style thin-crust slices. Customers often praise the flavor, crisp-yet-foldable crust, generous toppings, late hours, and iconic status. Common complaints include long lines, crowded dining areas, inconsistent service during busy periods, limited seating, and prices that some consider high for a slice. Reviews can also vary by branch and time of day. Before ordering, verify the exact address and check recent Google or Yelp reviews—particularly for delivery reliability and cleanliness.

Model gpt-5.5 through its API, asked 3 times, without web browsing. Answers differ from run to run, so we count runs, not a position.

Gemini Tone: positiveKnows you in 3 of 3 runs0

**Joe’s Pizza**, most famous for its original 1975 Greenwich Village location in New York City, is extremely reputable. It is widely considered an iconic staple of authentic New York-style pizza. **What people praise:** * **Classic NY Slice:** Renowned for its thin, crispy crust, rich tomato sauce, and perfectly balanced mozzarella. * **Speed & Value:** Fast service with high-quality, affordable slices. * **Authentic Vibe:** Simple, no-frills experience with nostalgic wall-to-wall celebrity photos. **What people complain about:** * **Crowds & Lines:** Long wait times, especially on weekends and late nights. * **Cramped Space:** Very limited seating; it is primarily a grab-and-go spot. * **High Expectations:** Some visitors feel it is slightly overhyped if they expect a complex gourmet pie rather than a traditional, classic slice.

Model gemini-3.6-flash through its API, asked 3 times, without web browsing. Answers differ from run to run, so we count runs, not a position.

The question we asked: “I am a customer in United States and I am thinking about using Joe's Pizza. What do you know about this business? Is it reputable? What do people praise and what do they complain about? Answer briefly, in under 150 words.”

Watch your own business every day

The same checks every day, with an alert by email, Slack, Teams, Discord or browser only when something can hurt. 14 days free, no card, then from $29 a month.

Start your 14-day trial

Growth plan free for 14 days: up to 5 businesses, all alert channels. No card.

Continue with Google
or with your email
No password. We email you a 6-digit code.

Results reflect what Google, Bing and the AI models returned at the time of the check, with the country set to the United States. Risk marks are automatic and can be wrong; open each page before acting.